Buh-Bye: Brooklyn's Most Controversial Judge Hanging Up His Robe EARLY

By Javier Sanchez | Sunday, 05 May 2024 10:15 PM
1
Views 3.4K
Image Credit : Photo by John Doe - The Daily Gazette

In a surprising turn of events, Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Matthew Sciarrino, known for his controversial rulings, has retired and is relocating to Florida.

This development comes just days after his contentious decision to release an alleged assailant, Franz Jeudy, who is accused of a random, unprovoked attack on Dulche Pichardo, a 57-year-old mother of three from Crown Heights.

Jeudy, 33, allegedly punched Pichardo in the face, resulting in a broken jaw. Prosecutors subsequently upgraded the charges against him to second-degree assault, a bail-eligible offense, and requested a $25,000 cash bail or $50,000 bond. However, Sciarrino, a seasoned Republican judge, dismissed the request.

This is not the first time Sciarrino has faced criticism for his rulings. Last year, he disregarded a prosecutor's plea to keep a repeat offender, Ousmane Diallo, in custody. Instead, he granted bail in an attempted murder case. Diallo was later accused of injuring two people in a shooting after being released on a $500,000 bond, according to authorities.

 WATCH: BIDEN CLAIMS INFLATION WAS 9% WHEN HE GOT IN OFFICEbell_image

Raul Gomez, Pichardo's son, expressed relief at Sciarrino's departure. "Good riddance, honestly," he told The Post. "Hopefully the next judge will be wiser and less ridiculous in his decisions... Hopefully they appoint better judges, although I'm skeptical that will happen."

 WATCH VIVEK: "WHAT IS THE CRIME THAT DONALD TRUMP COMMITTED?"bell_image

Gomez also criticized New York's lenient bail laws and expressed concern for his mother's safety, given Jeudy's release. "She's very upset because she thinks that there's a possibility that he could do it again, especially given that he’s been doing it so many times," Gomez said.

 NIGHT OPERATION UNCOVERS THE TRAGIC FATE OF THREE MUSICAL FESTIVAL HOSTAGES IN GAZA TUNNELbell_image

Jeudy has a history of similar offenses. He was arrested for two other random punches – one on a law enforcement officer in 2018 and the other on a security guard in 2019. Both charges were later dismissed as Jeudy, who reportedly has a history of schizophrenia, was deemed unfit to stand trial.

 WILL BIDEN’S DEBATE DEMANDS TURN THE TIDE OR DROWN HIS CHANCES?bell_image

Despite the recent controversy, Sciarrino's retirement and move to Florida had been planned for months, according to friends and neighbors. A court spokesperson confirmed that he filed his retirement papers in January and insisted that his decision was not influenced by the backlash over the bail ruling in Jeudy's case.

 CAPITOL RECOGNITION: A TRUE AMERICAN EVANGELIST EARNS BIG HONOR...bell_image

Sciarrino defended his decision to release Jeudy, stating that he followed state law. "You can't set bail on someone" who "is not a flight risk," he told The Post. He also described his nearly two-decade career on the bench as "wonderful" and insisted that his retirement decision was not related to past controversial rulings.

 BIDEN’S HONORARY DEGREE: A SYMBOL OF DIVISION AT MOREHOUSE COLLEGE?bell_image

Councilman Robert Holden, a moderate Queens Democrat who supports stricter bail laws, expressed satisfaction at Sciarrino's departure. "Good riddance to this soft-on-crime judge!" he said. "We need judges with the backbone to put bad guys behind bars, not ones that let out the entire world and then flee to Florida, where the laws are tougher."

X